Were the Planets Always in the Same Order?


It’s been more than twenty years since astronomers
began detecting planets around other stars. They weren’t surprised to find planets in
other star systems. But they were surprised by how those planets
were arranged, and they ended up having to rethink what they thought they knew about
how planets form. We used to think that our Solar System was
pretty standard, as star systems go. Our arrangement of four smaller inner rocky
planets and four bigger outer gaseous ones makes a lot of physical sense: When you’re farther away from the Sun, space
is colder, which allows more molecules to condense and build up larger planets. But then, we found our first exoplanet — the
first planet we’d discovered outside of our solar system. And it revealed a situation we used to think
was impossible. The first exoplanet was a world the size of
Saturn, orbiting more than seven times closer to its star than Mercury does to the Sun! There’s almost no way it could have formed
so close to its star — all the light gases would have boiled off before they could’ve
formed a planet. As astronomers collected more data, they started
to find more and more of these big, gas planets, which we now call Hot Jupiters, close to their
stars. They realized that Hot Jupiters migrated from
somewhere else, and they started trying to figure out how. Since then, they’ve come to realize that
planets can actually move around a lot in their early lives. Planets form in regions called protoplanetary
disks, made up of the leftover gas and dust after a star forms. We see these disks surrounding young stars
all over our galaxy. They provide a place for solid matter to clump
together, and eventually, the largest clumps become massive enough to pull in gas, giving
rise to worlds like Jupiter and Saturn. Once they form, these new planets are still
embedded in the protoplanetary disk. And that disk is the key to how they move
around. A new planet’s gravity affects the nearby
disk material, bunching it up into giant waves called spiral density waves. They’re the same kinds of structures that
give galaxies their arms and Saturn’s rings their details. There’s one density wave inside the planet’s
orbit, closer to the star, and one outside the planet’s orbit, on the side farther
from the star. Now, the closer you are to a star, the harder
its gravity pulls you and the faster you travel. So, over time, the wave towards the star starts
to creep ahead, while the one outside the planet’s orbit starts to fall behind. But these density waves are made up of actual,
physical stuff and therefore exert gravity of their own. So that wave ahead of the planet is pulling
it forward in its orbit, which gives the planet a little boost in energy, sending it a bit
farther from the star. Meanwhile, the wave behind the planet is doing
the exact opposite. Its gravity tugs the planet backwards, reducing
its energy and forcing it to fall into a smaller orbit. If these forces exactly balanced out, the
planet wouldn’t move at all, but usually the protoplanetary disk is less dense in some
places than others. That difference makes the pull of one wave
more powerful than the other, so the planet moves. In simulations, this process is so effective
at moving planets around that some scientists aren’t really sure why so many survive at
all. So, finally an explanation for how those strange
Hot Jupiters could exist where they do! They probably formed much farther away from
their stars before migrating in to where they are now. Even the planets in our own Solar System probably
migrated long ago. Astronomers call this idea the Nice Model,
after the city in France where it was developed. The Nice Model says that when the outer planets
were forming four and a half billion years ago, they were much more closely spaced than
they are today. Over time, interactions with the disk drove
them to where they are now, but they might have made some major detours along the way. Jupiter, for example, might have spent some
time in what today we’d call the inner Solar System. If it wandered close to the orbit of Mars
as both planets were forming, it could have dramatically reduced the amount of material
left to make the Red Planet. This would help explain why many models of
planet formation suggest that Mars should be roughly Earth-sized, when really, it only
has about a tenth of our mass! And Neptune may have started its life closer
to the Sun than Uranus. Then, once they began to move, they would
have swapped places. It might have taken hundreds of millions of
years for things to settle down to how we see them today. By that time, the disk of gas and dust would
have blown away, leaving behind only the scattered, rocky remains of planet formation. As those rocks encountered a world like Jupiter,
the planet’s gravity could have flung them towards the Sun — and in the process, propelled
the gas giant just a little bit farther. Slowly, the Solar System we know today took
shape — one rock at a time. And if our search for planets around other
stars has taught us anything, it’s that this is only one possible way things might
have played out. We now know that planets don’t just stay
put after they’re formed — there are all kinds of processes that can move them around. Thanks for watching this episode of SciShow
Space, and thanks especially to our patrons on Patreon who help make this show possible. If you want to help us keep making episodes
like this, just go to patreon.com/scishow to learn more. And don’t forget to go to youtube.com/scishowspace
and subscribe!

100 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *